Why Piano Students Struggle With Sight-Reading, and What the
Research Says We Can Do

Guest Post By Tomas Iglesias

I teach in Auckland, New Zealand, and every year I meet the same student. She plays her Grade 8 exam pieces with real polish. Then I put a Grade 2 sight-reading test on the stand, and things fall apart by the second line. If you don’t use graded exams, picture an advanced high schooler stopped cold by late- elementary music.

For years I put this down to nerves, or eyes stuck on the hands, or a student who just needed to do more of it. Then I started reading the research. Psychologists have been sitting pianists in front of eye trackers and memory tests for decades, and what they have found explained a lot of what I was seeing in lessons.

The main lesson is that sight-reading is several skills running at once. A student can be good at some and weak at others, and the fix depends on which one is letting them down.
Fluent readers read in chunks. A beginner looks at a C major chord and sees three separate notes. Each one has to be named, found on the keyboard, and played. An experienced reader sees one shape, and the hand goes to it.

Psychologists call this chunking, and it applies just as much to scales, broken chords, and familiar rhythms. The best-known study on this comes from Andrew Waters, Ellen Townsend, and Geoffrey Underwood, published in the British Journal of Psychology in 1998. They gave pianists a series of lab tasks and compared the results with how well each one could sight-read. The task most closely linked to sight-reading skill was a simple one: recalling a chord after seeing it for only a moment. Strong readers could take in a whole chord at a glance.

This explains why an unfamiliar piece can feel easy to an experienced player. The piece is new, but nearly everything in it is something they have played before.
It also means that theory and reading are the same job. A student who has chords and cadences in their hands has far less to read on the page. I tell my students that a master sight-reader is a master of chords.

How far ahead should the eyes be?
We all tell students to look ahead. Researchers measure this as the eye-hand span: the gap between the note the eyes are on and the note the hands are playing. Stronger readers do use their eyes more efficiently. A 2024 eye-tracking study of pianists at five conservatory levels found that the more advanced players read faster and more accurately, and their
eyes made fewer and shorter stops on the page.

The same study also had the pianists read atonal contemporary scores, and there everyone slowed down and needed more looks at the page. Their eyes were the same. The music had stopped being predictable. Reading skill is tied to the style a pianist knows, so a student who is going to sight-read Bach
needs to have read a lot of Baroque music first.

The second finding is about the span itself. A study of 30 professional pianists found that a long eye-hand span was not what set the best readers apart. What set them apart was that they changed it to suit the difficulty of the music. So, always reading a bar ahead is not quite right. A more useful instruction is to look ahead where the music is simple and let the eyes come back in where it gets thick. Holding the music in your head
Looking ahead creates a second problem. Once the eyes move on, the student has to hold what they just read until the hands catch up.

A 2023 study in PLOS ONE tested 39 pianists on this. Those with stronger auditory working memory, meaning the ability to hold sounds in mind for a few seconds, read further ahead. Those who read further ahead played better. The authors explain that written notes turn into imagined sound,
and the sound is what the brain holds on to and passes to the fingers.
The Waters study points the same way. Pianists who were good at matching a written bar to one they heard were also better sight-readers, over and above their skill at spotting patterns.

One caution.

These are links between abilities, found in fairly small groups. Nobody has shown that memory games make better sight-readers. But the findings are a good argument for something many of
us already do: have the student tap the rhythm and hum the shape of the tune before playing a note.

Knowing the pattern is different from playing it
Every teacher has heard it:  ‘I know what it is, I just can’t play it.’

Pamela Pike and a colleague tested this with 43 first-semester group-piano students. Over six classes, one group did pitch-pattern drills before sight-reading, one did rhythm drills, and a control group simply
rehearsed the examples. Both drill groups improved in more areas than the control group.

The interesting part is what the students said afterwards. They reported recognizing the patterns even when their hands could not keep up.
It is a small study, and I would not build a method on it. But it matches what I see. That student has a technique gap, and more sight-reading alone will not close it. What helps is getting the patterns into the hands: chord shapes, five-finger positions, and cadences in several keys, until the fingers know them
without help from the eyes.

What this looks like in a lesson: The research does not hand us one best routine, but it does tell us what to work on. This is how I would use it.

1. Go easy and go wide. Pick material well below the student’s playing level and use a lot of it. Patterns become familiar by turning up in hundreds of different pieces. In my experience, moving up one reading level takes something like 200 pieces at the current one.

2. Look before playing. Give the student thirty seconds to find the key, the meter, anything that repeats, and the places where a hand has to move. Anna Adamyan, a pianist and musicologist, has a fuller checklist of what to scan for.

3. Hear it first. Tap the rhythm. Hum the outline of the melody.

4. Choose a tempo they can keep. It should be slow enough that the eyes can get ahead. After that, no stopping.

5. Name the stumble. After a breakdown, ask what happened. Did they not know the note? Did they lose the rhythm? Or did they know both and not get there in time? Each one has a different fix.

6. Keep reading and practicing separate. By the third time through a page, the student is practicing it, and the reading has stopped. Sight-reading needs a steady supply of music they have never seen.

That supply is the hard part. Hymnals are excellent for it, and so are easy duet books and old method books from the thrift store. It is also the problem that led a group of us to start Piano Tree, a sight-reading app where students read graded pieces they have not seen before and get feedback as they
play.

I have written a longer guide to piano sight-reading there if you want more detail. But a pile of easy books and fifteen minutes a day will take a student a long way.

When a student tells me they are just bad at sight-reading, I ask which part. Most of them turn out to be good at some of it. They hear well but read one note at a time, or they see the chord and cannot reach it in time.
Find the weak part and teach that. Then keep the easy music coming.

About the author

Tomas Iglesias is a pianist, composer, and teacher in Auckland, New Zealand, where he directs the

School of Musical Arts. He has taught piano for more than 15 years and is one of the founders of Piano Tree, a piano sight-reading app that works with acoustic pianos and MIDI keyboards.

To learn more, visit Piano Tree

Research cited
• Waters, A. J., Townsend, E., & Underwood, G. (1998). Expertise in musical sight reading: A study
of pianists. British Journal of Psychology, 89(1), 123-149.
• Perra, J., Poulin-Charronnat, B., Baccino, T., Bard, P., Pfister, P., Lalitte, P., Zerbib, M.,  Drai-
Zerbib, V. (2024). Markers of musical expertise in a sight-reading task: An eye-tracking study.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition.
• Lim, Y., Park, J. M., Rhyu, S.-Y., Chung, C. K., Kim, Y Yi, S. W. (2019). Eye-hand span is not an
indicator of but a strategy for proficient sight-reading in piano performance. Scientific Reports,
9, 17906.

• Imai-Matsumura, K., & Mutou, M. (2023). The influence of executive functions on eye-hand span
and piano performance during sight-reading. PLOS ONE.
• Pike, P. D., & Carter, R. (2010). Employing cognitive chunking techniques to enhance sight-
reading performance of undergraduate group-piano students. International Journal of Music
Education, 28(3), 231-246.


Comments & Discussion

Leave a Reply